With the efficiency of decision 'illusion' to witness this circuit

Aafia Siddiqui's lawyer, his client is mentally insane, but still byeongyiiteul jurisdiction and personnel of the United States in Afghanistan and the killing of police officers in 2008 for studies of the compound itself may not testify in defense of the two on 10 May, according to a federal appeals court.
MS Siddiqui is now an attorney Dawn Cardi soon as paranoid schizophrenic delusions, because he witnesses at the trial in 2010, not in the setting can appreciate what is happening sentenced to 86 years in prison for the Second Circuit provide EALs an application before the court argued that the United States.
Both at trial and Judge Richard M. Cardi Co-Counsel in an unusual location of the request Berman (see profile) the testimony of Ms Siddiqui, United States - Pakistan - Education Neurology, Miss Siddiqui to prevent more serious objection.
Judge Richard Wesley (see profile) and Susan Carney (see profile) by a sitting judge District Court for the Eastern District Roslynn Mauskopf (see profile), formerly the 10th February oral argument that testified on both sides in the Cardi Siddiqui denied a meaningful decision about whether he do it could not claim that can not appreciate the impact of networking, suffered a mental illness, refused lawyers, along with the show, "because some of the fantastic. "
Judge Wesley, no matter how wrong it may be decided by the defendant to testify in his defense have the authority to fundamental principles, both for the improvement of the status given Cardi asked.
"I just want to have customers, how can I say?" Judge Wesley asked. "He understood what he was going did not know is suffering from a mental illness that prevents the heart of the assessment of the differences, but the color?"
"Sure," said Cardi MS.
Control system in comparison to the United States Siddiqui, 10 to 3916-CR for more than an hour from women Cardi and secondary attorney asked Jenna and Jesse Furman Dabbs. MS Dabbs, David Rody an agency with a lawyer, Christopher Lavigne and prosecution of cases.
MS Siddiqui attempted murder and sentenced him to three days in February 2010, trying to U.S. officials, officers and employees of the United States and the number and duration of single-use and violent crime in connection with charges of weapons possession, theft, four types of murder in U.S. citizens and employees.
MS Siddiqui, now 39, says he is looking more worried about their behavior as suicide bombers in July 2008, Afghan police arrested 17 days bars. How dirty bombs and the Empire State Building and the Brooklyn Bridge, including making a list of what you look like a target, including sodium cyanide, biological warfare in the hands of two pounds of documents found in her bag.
U.S. personnel arrived in a police compound in July 2008 after 18 days questioning the amount Siddiqui, he argued, placed behind a curtain of American officers and cries arose, were several shots fired M-4 rifle and grabbed the "I want Americans and the Americans to kill the death. "quiet" MS Siddiqui were killed with a shot in the stomach.
He questioned the purpose of gathering information from FBI agents guarding her gunshot wound while being treated at a hospital and spent 16 hours.
Siddiqui MS, but without firing a question claims in a statement. After consulting with his boss, Miranda warnings for non-employees, with the statements I have heard Miss Siddiqui.
When the government refused as evidence of Bergamo judge president to allow this statement, but if they charge to witness evidence available seats, MS Siddiqui said.
In pre-trial and trial Judge Berman was forced to walk a tightrope with MS Siddiqui. He stood up and shouted in court, including cases is explosive, "You liar" Government first witness. Sometimes defense table sat slumped a few patients by the Pakistani authorities both Linda Cardi Moreno, Charles Swift and his team of defense, have not been detained, including Sharp, refused to Elaine.
The study of tight security represented, and at one point, Judge Berman was a member of the audience after they threatened by the fear of doenyi jury to award.
Judge whether the argument, Miss Siddiqui at least for two days on the 28th January 2010, before she testified to hearing it should not be allowed to testify.
His face covered with a scarf, he was shot and killed two U.S. soldiers, when he claimed that he only tried out secretly.
He claimed to have fired a gun and take the "big joke." While both the intersection of Dabbs, when asked, "Are you not?" MS Siddiqui, "I tell you what you know ... I would hang curtains and Riga in the U.S. military around the bots irresponsible not believe chongeuldugo shot," said
So, among others, statements led to admit that he shot Mrs. Siddiqui, the claim of hospital beds for Miss Dabbs could not be opened.
Ask for evidence
During the hearing, 10th February-day report both Cardi in a hospital bed with his client caught, because there was not under the influence of Percocet and other painkillers voluntarily, and 8 to 12 hours to recover from a gunshot wound, "for example, was called into question."
Judge Berman said women's Cardi the statement was a voluntary decision whether a thorough analysis of all elements failed to perform.
But still there is error, the judge innocuous assumptions that Wesley needed? Ultimately, he "identified himself as Six Shooter," he added cautiously, and presented a different scene.
Cardi both the physical evidence found in this area, not "one of the spheres" was said not to support witness statements, he said only a few cartridges.
MS Dabbs report directly to the judge in Bergamo is accused phones have. "The court correctly voluntary statements to FBI agents have found to stop because it could be used to argue in court to be made," the report "Testing the totality of the circumstances," he said to meet.
Miranda warnings given to the chorus of "conscious decision" by Judge Carney, when asked, MS Dabbs, the FBI agents, shooting, and MS Siddiqui reports for presentation to the hospital that she did not say, "around."
"They [the agent] purpose [was] intelligent interviews. Extract confessions or statements can not be condemned," MS Dabbs said.
Dabbs, Miss Siddiqui at both the trial he was arrested by Afghan police when asked about his case was found in the document in question. His case does "not affect the substance of the claims.
"I can not attest to it because you do not need everything I bag to go," he said.
"Do you have a recording of a dirty bomb?" MS Dabbs said.

"To answer your question, I do not know how to make dirty bombs," he said. "I'm not a good singer can not draw, you can say." On 10 February, MS Dabbs amount of documents in a suitcase in hand, some of Siddiqui, found written introduction, and said the documents were "very proof of motive and purpose."
Behavior 'count'?
An essential part of the Cardi Miss Siddiqui and adjust the offense level and his criminal history category, § 3A1.4 Terrorism decision rules increases, an increase of less than planned.
Improvements to any of these crimes of the first defendant to be implemented with several second act, the government crime behavior or action in retaliation for the government, the "calculation" is carried out.
Both sides argue over the meaning of the term "calculations."
Cardi said improvements or the amount of "carefully prepared before the event" is used, the "every day of the incident" between two of his clients, he acts as if all by itself, making it the "long-term efforts are things to treat "but influence or retaliation from desire.
But Mr. Furman aspects of the plan, "the core of its attractive long-term need for" a panel discussion, but to strengthen the "third reading requirements," the court would be a mistake.
"The court suggested that it was necessary," says Mr. Furman.